Students that are parcipating in the Stargirl enrichment project will post their thoughts and questions about the reading they are doing.
PLEASE DO NOT INCLUDE YOUR LAST NAMES ON YOUR POSTS.
Wednesday, November 12, 2008
General questions
Do you agree or disagree with Stargirl's decision to change who she is? Why?
6 comments:
Anonymous
said...
I do not agree with her choice to change who she is. I thought that her old self was way better. She was so much nicer. Joan R. Set 7
I dont agree with the choice Stargirl made because she didnt even really want to change. Leo was telling her that changing would make her normal and wich might lead to being popular. Leo brainwashed Stargirl. TommyR. set 4
I disagree with her choice because she shouldn't have to change herself just to make people like her. She was just fine before and people should just deal with her instead of shunning her. -Kevin W. Set 7
I don't think that Stargirl should have changed into susan. She should be fine with who she is and Leo should have thought more before her told her which is what caused her to change. Jordan C. Set 4
I believe that Stargirl did the right thing by changing what she looked like because in the book she changed her appearance but she didn't change who she was. Her change helped her realize even more clearly that she shouldn't change what she looks like or who she is. Basicaly it was an experiment. After Stargirl left; Leo realized that he liked her just as she was. Although when she changed he was thrilled thinking the shunning would go away but it didn't. He realized to late that he didn't care what she looked like. Deanna P. Set 4
6 comments:
I do not agree with her choice to change who she is. I thought that her old self was way better. She was so much nicer.
Joan R. Set 7
i disagree with star girl changing who she is because it doesnt matter what others think as long as you know that your doing the right thing.
I dont agree with the choice Stargirl made because she didnt even really want to change. Leo was telling her that changing would make her normal and wich might lead to being popular. Leo brainwashed Stargirl. TommyR. set 4
I disagree with her choice because she shouldn't have to change herself just to make people like her. She was just fine before and people should just deal with her instead of shunning her.
-Kevin W. Set 7
I don't think that Stargirl should have changed into susan. She should be fine with who she is and Leo should have thought more before her told her which is what caused her to change.
Jordan C. Set 4
I believe that Stargirl did the right thing by changing what she looked like because in the book she changed her appearance but she didn't change who she was. Her change helped her realize even more clearly that she shouldn't change what she looks like or who she is. Basicaly it was an experiment. After Stargirl left; Leo realized that he liked her just as she was. Although when she changed he was thrilled thinking the shunning would go away but it didn't. He realized to late that he didn't care what she looked like.
Deanna P. Set 4
Post a Comment